Men beaten for speaking Portuguese in Bristol

Trusted article source icon
Monday, March 09, 2009
Profile image for This is Bristol

This is Bristol

Two men were savagely beaten and robbed by a gang of up to 20 thugs in Bristol – for speaking Portuguese.

Friends Shane Braga, 28, and Marcio Toso, 30, were kicked and punched to floor in a frenzied, late-night attack in Crow Lane, Henbury.

The pair – who said police later told them the area was a "no-go zone" – had a laptop and keys for two cars stolen during the incident in the early hours of Sunday.

As they walked from Mr Braga's flat towards Mr Toso's car, they were approached by a group of four girls.

They were asked what language they were speaking and within seconds a large group emerged from out of the darkness.

Mr Braga, who blacked out in the attack, was left with chipped teeth, a black eye and a swollen and badly bruised head.

Mr Toso, who lives in Southmead, needed 10 stitches in his forehead and was left with a broken nose.

Mr Braga, who grew up in America and is awaiting news of his application to become a UK resident, told the Post: "I was walking Marcio to his car and the next thing I know I'm being punched in the back of the head.

"The beating must have continued for more than 10 minutes, but I blacked out so it could have been longer.

"It got to the point where I gave up trying to fend them off. They were screaming abuse at me.

"All I remember saying is: 'What is wrong with you people?'.

"If this attack had happened in Brazil and two English men had been beaten, it would have been all over the news.

"In the UK, all the police can say is: 'Crow Lane? The area is full of no-hopers and it's a no-go zone.'

"I'm now frightened to leave my own house.

"The police have left it up to me to contact the media to get help to catch our attackers. It's ridiculous.

"I'm now waiting for my and my wife's cars to be stolen, as they have the keys for both vehicles."

He added: "Marcio doesn't speak very good English, that's why we were chatting in Portuguese."

The gang only stopped beating Mr Braga when a passing driver sounded her horn.

Mr Toso, who has dual Brazilian and Italian citizenship but has lived in the UK for the past year, also managed to break free to get help.

Speaking in broken English, he said: "They took my laptop computer but luckily I managed to get away. I ran back to Shane's flat to get his flatmates, but not before they hit and kicked me."

Officers are checking CCTV cameras in the area to see if they captured the incident.

Avon and Somerset police said they were not currently treating the incident as a racially motivated attack and refused to accept that the area was a no-go zone.

The attack on Mr Braga and Mr Toso is the latest in a series of incidents to plague the Crow Lane area.

In January a 15-year-old girl was dragged into bushes at the side of the road at knifepoint and attacked as she walked to nearby Henbury School. She managed to escape with minor injuries to her neck, after struggling free from her male attacker.

In October last year evening bus services had to be temporarily diverted away from Crow Lane after a series of attacks by yobs throwing stones and fireworks. The attacks came just two weeks after Home Secretary Jacqui Smith visited the area to be told its problems with crime and anti-social behaviour were being effectively tackled.

Last June a woman with learning difficulties was left traumatised after being dragged to the ground by a mugger on a bike who grabbed her handbag as he cycled past. The robber was later jailed for 21 months.

In 2005 a newsagent suffered head injuries after catching a shoplifter who then attacked him with an iron bar.

A number of measures to tackle yobs has also been put in place. A new CCTV system monitored by the city council's emergency control room was installed around the shops in January last year.

And the Co-op store in Crow Lane began piping classical music out of its doors in 2004 in an attempt to stop troublemakers hanging around outside.

A force spokeswoman said: "There have been no other significant reports of trouble in the area.

"Both victims were treated by paramedics at the scene and taken to Frenchay Hospital.

"They were assaulted by a mixed group of men and women.

"We are appealing for witnesses who saw the attack to contact police."

Anyone with information should contact Crimestoppers on 0800 555 111 or ring police on 0845 456 7000.

23
Tweet this article
Report

23 Comments

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Rick, Boston MA

    Tuesday, March 17 2009, 1:03AM

    “Marcio you will come out of this as a better person. Hang in there keep the faith.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by JoJo, USA

    Sunday, March 15 2009, 10:08PM

    “Brazilian or not, I am very proud that these two men are speaking up for a community that obviously does not take any crime prevention measures from their paid law enforcement officers. Because of the police over looking this problem, the trash take over a community and innocent people live in silence and fear. I am proud that Marcio and Shane have the courage to speak out.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Just Being Realistic, Bristol

    Friday, March 13 2009, 7:58PM

    “I totally agree with Simon and Mark. I'm Brazilian. I love Brazil and I love England. We just need to be realistic. What has just happened here, unfortunately, happens everywhere in the world and comparing Brazil and England, everybody should know it is pretty much worse in Brazil than in England. And I'm not defending England saying these things about Brazil. This is not my opinion. It's just a matter of fact.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Simon Ingles, Central Sao Paulo

    Thursday, March 12 2009, 7:19PM

    “No Marcus, Juliana... I think my problem is that you can tell I am a gringo from 100m away, no watches or jewellry. And every time I have had trouble it's been in a "nice" area (Higeonopolis, Faria Lima, Itaim, Ana Rosa) during daylight.

    - Mark I agree with. The fact that the boys were Brazilian was unfortunate, not contrived. Don't worry, there are NO hordes of Englishmen running around the streets looking for Brazilians to assault.

    - And Marcus is totally right. English isn't spoken across half the world because we are a shy polite people. But I do resent this "holier than thou" attitude.”

  • Profile image for This is Bristol

    by Mark, Bristol

    Thursday, March 12 2009, 12:34PM

    “Marcus, this attack was not because they were speaking another language. That was merely a conversation starter for the girls so that the boys could swarm around them.
    This would and could have happened to anyone, regardless of nationality or race.”

        Add your comments

        max 4000 characters
         
         
         
         
         
         

        Tell us about your area

        Got some interesting news? Write about it and let your whole community know.

          Write an article